Setting KPI’s in Blurry Situations

Setting key performance indicators (KPIs) is one of the most important tasks an agency can do. It’s not an easy one, though. An important conversation needs to happen to determine what to measure, how and why. And of course, the more detailed and accurate, the better.

In a perfect world

In a marketer’s perfect world, it would be possible to track everything with complete clarity. But we don’t live in a perfect world. There’s always going to be channel overlap and actions happening that can’t be measured. The question then arises:

If we can’t define KPIs perfectly, should we define them at all?

This used to worry me because I wanted our clients to have flawless KPIs all the time, no matter what. And if it wasn’t perfect, well, maybe it shouldn’t be a KPI. But then I realised:

A KPI is by definition an indicator.

An indicator does not have to be infallible; it’s designed to be discussed in context as a component of a greater whole.

With this in mind, setting KPIs became a must. Even if they’re not perfect. Especially if they’re not perfect!

So, if you’ve not yet set any KPIs for your online marketing efforts, here are some easy-to-start suggestions for anyone with Google Analytics:

  • Users – the total number of users who interacted with your website
  • Sources – contribution by source (e.g. organic, paid, etc.)
  • Engagement – average time on site, page depth, pages viewed, etc.
  • Views of key pages – with particular strategic importance
  • Conversion goals – by type and volume (e.g. product sale, form fill enquiry, phone calls)
  • Conversion goal value per conversion – because some conversions are worth more than others

All of these should be measured:

  • Month on month
  • Year on year
  • By device

The key with getting KPIs right is to do the best job possible with what’s available, and to ensure discussions include as much background info, insight, and interpretation as possible.

Planning a new website this year? Get the Website Redesign Checklist

Subscribe to download

Every year, several of our clients redesign their websites.

When this happens, there’s a lot to think about.

  • SEO. How do we smoothly transition rankings and traffic?
  • Ad campaigns. Are we updating ad copy, URLs, tracking?
  • Conversion rates. Can we make sure the new site converts better than the old?

Most checklists online (and books) only cover website redesign from one perspective, e.g. SEO. That’s great but incomplete.

None cover SEO, PPC and CRO, together, in a digestible way.

Which is why we needed to create this.

It contains the top 30 highest-priority items to consider packed into two easy-to-print pages. It’s perfect for guiding your team and agency.

Get your checklist now

How we can help you

We can help you drive digital marketing performance by using the world’s most powerful digital marketing channels to full effect

How we can help you

Get a proposal

Would you like to see how Reef can improve your digital marketing campaigns? We welcome the opportunity to share our best ideas with you

Get a proposal